We visited the Butcher (AKA Walnut Grove, AKA North Lewisburg) Cemetery on Saturday, September 5, 2009. A broken stone for Capt. James M. S. Butcher was found at the back of the cemetery.
I carried it down the hill of the cemetery and placed it in front of his father's (Dr. J. M. Butcher) stone.
Thanks to a collateral line Butcher descendant, I have a copy of the obituary for Captain James M. S. Butcher. It is posted it here as well as a close up view of Captain Butcher's broken stone.
The Butcher Cemetery had five known Civil War veterans; and now we know it has six.