Exploring Almost Forgotten Gravesites in the Great State of Ohio

Dedicated to cemetery preservation in the great state of Ohio


"A cemetery may be considered as abandoned when all or practically all of the bodies have been Removed therefrom and no bodies have been buried therein for a great many years, and the cemetery has been so long neglected as entirely to lose its identity as such, and is no longer known, recognized and respected by the public as a cemetery. 1953 OAG 2978."

Sunday, September 7, 2014

Spotlighting Milldale Cemetery (AKA School Land Cemetery), New Boston, Scioto County, Ohio

Thanking Andrea Smith Nelson for the cemetery and grave marker photographs, Eva Smith for the obituaries, and Mindy 'Malinda' Huffman Cook for sharing the Milldale Cemetery map.  
 ~*~*~*~*~~*
Milldale Cemetery needs much improved maintenance and restoration of several gravestones.


From Eva Smith:   

"Eliza Ellen Presley Bailey and sons David and Joseph Jr."

"Eliza Ellen Presley Bailey – 1888-1930, metal marker. Eliza Ellen Bailey, 40, gave birth to her seventh child, son David Marshall Bailey, on 10 Dec 1930 and died the next day in Mercy hospital. Infant son David died in June 1931, six months after his mother’s death, and his brother Joseph W. Bailey Jr., 4, died the next month, in July 1931, after being struck by a car. Mrs. Bailey was born in Scioto County, Ohio, a daughter of Howard and Lettie Presley and spent most of her life in Portsmouth, Ohio. She was a member of the New Boston Christian Church. She was survived by her husband Joseph W. Bailey Sr.; six children, Nellie, Robert, Albert, Virginia, Joseph W. Jr., and David; a brother, John Presley of Columbus, Ohio; and three sisters, Mary Locher of New Boston, Ohio, Laura Schomberg and Hattie Neal of Hicksville, Ohio. Her son David’s obituary lists another child, Ruth, who preceded him in death. Services for Mrs. Bailey were held from the Emrick funeral home with Walter Bagley officiating. Note: A funeral notice says that interment was in Greenlawn cemetery. However, family members say she was buried in the Milldale Cemetery and a 1997 cemetery inventory supports that. Sources: 1. 1997 Campbell-Underwood inventory, No. 59 on the map. 2. Family members. 3. Obituaries, The Portsmouth Times, 11 Dec 1930, Page 17, and 12 Dec 1930, Page 25.

David Marshall Bailey – 1930-1931, metal marker. David was born 10 Dec 1930 in Ohio, a son of Joseph H. Bailey Sr. and Eliza Ellen Presley Bailey. His mother died the next day. David died six months later on 14 Jun 1931. In addition to his father, David was survived by brothers Albert, Robert and Joseph Jr. and sisters Virginia and Nellie. A sister Ruth preceded him in death. Sources: 1. 1997 Campbell-Underwood inventory, No. 58 on the map. 2. Obituary, The Portsmouth Times, 15 June 1931, Page 13. 3. Ohio death records.

Joseph W. Bailey Jr. – 1925-1931. Metal marker. Joseph W. Bailey Jr., 4, died after being hit by an automobile around midnight on 25 July 1931. According to a newspaper article, the little boy had stepped out into the street from behind a parked car. The driver, who was exonerated, rushed the Joseph to the hospital. Joseph was a son of J.W. Bailey Sr. and the late Eliza Ellen Presley Bailey. 

This was the third death in the Bailey family within a few months. Mrs. Bailey died in December 1930 after giving birth to her seventh child, David. David, six months old, died in June 1931, a month before Joseph was killed. Mrs. Bailey and David are also buried in the Milldale Cemetery. Joseph was survived by his father, sisters Nellie and Virginia, and brothers Robert and Albert. Sources: 1. 1997 Campbell-Underwood inventory, No. 57 on the map. 2. family members. 3. Child Suffers Fatal Injury; Struck By Auto, The Sunday Portsmouth Times, 26 July 1931, Page 1. 4. obituary, Rites Tuesday For Bailey Boy, The Portsmouth Times, 27 July 1931, Page 2."
 
 

From Eva Smith:     
 
"This looks like: "Rice, Corpl. William M. -- 1982 inventory notes: “Co C 40Ky Mt Inf. Broken and leaning against tree.” 1997 inventory: No. 61 on map. Tombstone photo taken 2010. Sources: 1. 1982 Ramsey inventory. 2. 1997 Campbell-Underwood inventory." 
The tombstone is in worse shape than in 2010."


 
 


Tuesday, September 2, 2014

Time is Running Out to Express Your Cemetery Concerns to the Ohio Cemetery Law Task Force -- Next Meeting Open to the Public is Scheduled for Friday, September 19, 2014

The Ohio Cemetery Task Force has been meeting monthly in Columbus since January, 2014.   

Their report and recommendations are due to the Governor, Speaker of the House, and President of the Senate by September 29, 2014.

Speaking for myself, I am particularly troubled by one of the paragraphs that is in the July 25, 2014 meeting minutes that appears under Section III. "New Business" :

"Mr. Russell then expressed his belief that all cemeteries need to be protected including the tombstones that are artifacts about the people. Tombstones can be interpreted to show the economic status of the family by the type and size of stone used; if there was a stonecutter in the community; where the stone came from tells us about the trade between people; and decorations
and epitaphs which reveal to us much about the community itself. While these cemeteries do not
need to be maintained the same as registered cemeteries they do need some protection. The task
force members agreed with Mr. Russell’s statements and concluded that the statements should be
added as part of the justification under criminal sanctions."

***********
I agree that ALL cemeteries need to be protected, however, unfortunately in the State of Ohio the filing of a Cemetery Complaint to the Ohio Dispute Resolution Commission can only be made on behalf of registered cemeteries -- those with burials within the past 25 years and those that are not considered to be  'family cemeteries.' 

Cemeteries that do not meet the above-stated requirements are not eligible to be registered. Thus as non-registered cemeteries they are deemed to be ineligible to be included in the process of filing formal complaints against those who are responsible for them.  This includes for reasons such as lack of routine maintenance or any other issues negatively impacting them.  

This discrimination means relegating literally thousands of Ohio's oldest and most vulnerable cemeteries to be classified as inactive cemeteries and not eligible for the same protections as active cemeteries.     

 Active = Registered        Inactive = Non-Registered

"While these cemeteries do not need to be maintained the same as registered cemeteries they do need some protection." 

The one sentence directly above above fails to explain any reasons why the members of the Ohio Cemetery Law Task Force conclude "these cemeteries do not need to be maintained the same as registered cemeteries...." And "need some protection" -- why would they need any less protection than registered cemeteries??  Descendants and family researchers do visit inactive and abandoned cemeteries, and gravestone conservation workshops have been held in them to cite two reasons for maintaining  them.    

**********

 Ohio Revised Code - "Lawriter" & Registered Cemetery Information
 
Dennis Ginty; May 7, 2013: 

"The Division does not register cemeteries that are family cemeteries and it doesn’t register cemeteries that have not had an interments during that last 25 years.  A Family cemetery is defined as “a cemetery that contains the human remains of persons, at least three-fourths of whom have a common ancestor or who are the spouse or adopted child of that common ancestor.” 
 

"Yes, you are correct that the minimum maintenance guidelines apply to registered cemeteries (Ohio Revised Code Section 4767.06 (H)).  The Cemetery Dispute Resolution Commission does not have the authority to create minimum maintenance guidelines for non-registered cemeteries." 

"Ohio Revised Code Section 4767.07 states a person may file a complaint against any person operating or maintaining a cemetery registered pursuant to section 4767.03.  The Division does not have jurisdiction to take complaints against unregistered cemeteries.  We are not aware of any other complaint process." 

~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*

The next Ohio Cemetery Law Task Force Meeting is open to the public and scheduled for:

Friday, September 19th at 10:00 a.m.
77 South High Street, 22nd Floor, Columbus, OH 43215

If you are not able to attend this meeting in person, please consider contacting:

Ohio Cemetery Task Force Co-Chairperson:

Anne.Petit@com.state.oh.us 

Anne M. Petit
Superintendent
Ohio Department of Commerce
Division of Real Estate & Professional Licensing
Direct dial: 614-466-3411
Fax number: 614-644-0584
Office number: 614-466-4100
 
Or

Per the August 20, 2014 meeting minutes, Mr. Patrick Paccininni, general counsel for ODOT, will be the designated chair person at the September 19, 2014 meeting.  

Patrick Paccininni
Phone #: 614-446-7200
patrick.paccininni@dot.state.oh.us

Thursday, August 28, 2014

Sharing a New Blog: "Gehio" -- "Geocaching+History+Ohio = A Tour Of Ohio Valley History"

"Gehio" -- "Geocaching+History+Ohio = A Tour Of Ohio Valley History"  is a new blog featured here under the category of "Miscellaneous Blogs of  Interest" in the right-hand column of links.  
 ~*~*~*~*~*~
Thanking "Gehio" for including a new blog post about "Exploring Almost Forgotten Gravesites in Ohio" and a link to this blog in the nice listing of links.
 ~*~*~*~*~*~
Below is a sampling of the cemetery-related blog posts to date for you to explore from "Gehio":

"This Blog"

Feb 08, 2012
Geocaching sometimes takes me to interesting and forgotten places that pique my curiosity after scratching the surface a bit. Hillcrest Cemetery, a Cincinnati OH cemetery on Sutton Road in Anderson Township is one of those ...
Sep 15, 2011
His body was thought to be about 1000 ft away next to some old railroad tracks in what was the once weed filled and trash strewn forgotten Fulton Cemetery with no legible tombstones. I actually tried to locate Fulton once to ...
Dec 19, 2013
Cemetery geocaches are some of my favorite hides, especially historical cemeteries. In November 2013 I saw a string of old cemeteries that had no geocaches so I changed that. Brethren Historic Cemetery This cemetery has ...
 ~*~*~*~*~*~
"Cemetery geocaches are some of my favorite hides, especially historical cemeteries. In November 2013 I saw a string of old cemeteries that had no geocaches so I changed that."

Brethren Historic Cemetery 
This cemetery has a section with headstones moved from another cemetery but they left the bodies behind.

Willsey Historic Cemetery
One of the many Colerain Township historical cemeteries.

Asbury Historic Cemetery and Chapel
I wasn't able to find much information about this old cemetery and chapel other than it dates back to 1836, the original chapel was destroyed in a storm and was rebuilt in 1868.

 *****
While browsing through the blog posts found on  "Gehio" you'll discover a nice variety of Ohio-themed topics that make for fascinating historical reading; and along the way learn more about the fun connections you can find from  Geocaching.